Dave Grossman, director of design at Back to the Future and Jurassic Park developer Telltale Games, reviewed tools for game writers and designers who implement the "hand of fate" at a presentation at GDC Online in Austin today. To Grossman, it's up to the writer and designer to decide how this "hand of fate" will direct players through a game's story. He conveyed two extremes of authorial control: At the beginning of his lecture, a Powerpoint slide simply stated, "Let's play a game... Ready Set Go!" And that was it – an example of the ultimate sandbox game in which you have no constraints. Problem is, with zero authorial direction from a game designer, there is also no fun. "It's pretty easy for a sandbox to turn into a desert" with no direction whatsoever, said Grossman. Grossman then had attendees draw a tic-tac-toe grid, and told them where to put the Xs and Os, until the Xs won. It's a game, technically, but the "hand of fate" in that instance takes entirely too much control away from the player. "It was like watching a movie of someone playing tic-tac-toe," he said. Between those two extremes, games with varying degrees of authorial control and direction can successfully convey compelling stories. "Which things are meddled with is more important than to what degree," Grossman explained. He compared two games, Portal and Secret of Monkey Island, both revered for their storytelling, but which go about it in entirely different ways. Monkey Island's hand of fate was heavy, and the writers had a strong vision of the path that they want to guide the player through. Portal gives players a tool – the portal gun – to experience the game's environments and "characters," and progress through the game. Both games took different approaches, but authorial voice was implemented in such a way that both games were successful. There are many "hand of fate" tools that game designers and writers have at their disposal, explained Grossman, with cut scenes being one of the most obvious. While that's one way to tell a story, it takes away control from the player, and that can be "dangerous" said Grossman, as video games' distinguishing feature is their interactivity. A step away from cut scenes are what Grossman just called "scenes, which don't take control away from players, but allow them to walk around and interact with an environment while, for example, an NPC is talking. However, this may actually cause the player to miss important information while being distracted by the interactivity. A game's architecture can be a more interactive approach to implementing authorial voice – a narrow hallway or bridge that gives players little option but to forge ahead allows the game designer's intention to come through loud and clear, said Grossman. It's an aggressive approach, but only giving the player one option for movement gives the author a strong voice without totally taking away control. Grossman said that architecture can also be used as a lure as opposed to a constraint, such as a distant tower that beckons adventuring gamers from across a landscape. In the end, it's up to the writer and designer to decide just how heavy the "hand of fate" should be when creating a game – should the designer be mostly absent? Aggressive? Omnipresent? "The hand of fate is your hand. I hope you use it wisely," said Grossman.
GDC Online: Using The 'Hand Of Fate' In Game Design
Oct. 10, 2011

Tags:
event-gdc
Subscribe to our newsletter
About JikGuard.com
JikGuard.com, a high-tech security service provider focusing on game protection and anti-cheat, is committed to helping game companies solve the problem of cheats and hacks, and providing deeply integrated encryption protection solutions for games.
Top

David Dastmalchian Comments On M. Bison Role, Says He's Playing Lots Of STREET FIGHTER 2
July 28, 2025

MORTAL KOMBAT II Producer Teases Third Installment And Potential Spin-Offs
July 28, 2025

GOD OF WAR Showrunner Ronald D. Moore Discusses The Prime Video Adaptation's Tone And Development Progress
July 28, 2025

UKIE responds to adult games being pulled from Steam and itch.io after pressure from payment providers
July 28, 2025

The studio behind Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Mutants Unleashed brings in union after facing closure
July 28, 2025
Recent

David Dastmalchian Comments On M. Bison Role, Says He's Playing Lots Of STREET FIGHTER 2
July 28, 2025

MORTAL KOMBAT II Producer Teases Third Installment And Potential Spin-Offs
July 28, 2025

GOD OF WAR Showrunner Ronald D. Moore Discusses The Prime Video Adaptation's Tone And Development Progress
July 28, 2025

UKIE responds to adult games being pulled from Steam and itch.io after pressure from payment providers
July 28, 2025

The studio behind Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Mutants Unleashed brings in union after facing closure
July 28, 2025

Some game firms are struggling with the complexities of the UK Online Safety Act
July 28, 2025

Sony sues Tencent for "slavish clone" of its "valuable" Horizon franchise
July 28, 2025

Puzzle & Dragons publisher/developer GungHo Online faces shareholder revolt
July 28, 2025

Dating App Breach Exposes Images of 13,000 Women
July 28, 2025

US Woman Gets Eight Years for Part in $17m North Korean Scheme
July 28, 2025
Blog

Security Risk Analysis for Racing Games
July 28, 2025

Are there hacks that increase gacha pull rates?
July 24, 2025

VMOS Open-Source: New Threat to Game Security
July 18, 2025

How Games Detect Black and Gray Studio
July 15, 2025

How Games Detect iOS Jailbreaks
July 11, 2025

FPS Game Anti-Cheat Solution
July 9, 2025

Black and Gray Industry Insights: HappyMod
July 7, 2025

Online Game Anti-Cheat Solution
July 4, 2025

iOS Code Encryption Solutions
June 26, 2025

Casual Game Security Risks Analysis and Solutions
June 25, 2025
Random

How to sync passkeys in Chrome across your PC, Mac, iPhone, or Android
July 25, 2025

13 tech trends to watch now, according to McKinsey (and no, it's not all AI)
July 25, 2025

Prolonged Chinese Cyber Espionage Campaign Targets VMware Appliances
July 25, 2025

Motorola will give you a free smartwatch with its latest foldable phone deal - how to qualify
July 25, 2025

David Dastmalchian Comments On M. Bison Role, Says He's Playing Lots Of STREET FIGHTER 2
July 28, 2025

MADDEN 26 Player Ratings: Predicting The Best Rated Quarterbacks (QBs)
July 26, 2025

Third-Party Breach Impacts Majority of Allianz Life US Customers
July 28, 2025

Should you buy a robot lawn mower with no boundary wire? My verdict after months of testing
July 25, 2025

iOS 26 envy? 5 iPhone features you can already use on your Android (Samsung included)
July 25, 2025

WOLFENSTEIN Live-Action TV Series In Development At Amazon
July 26, 2025
Most Views

How Games Detect GameGuardian
March 17, 2025

Explanation of Game Anti-Cheat Solutions
March 17, 2025

Cheat Engine Modifier Detection Solutions
March 18, 2025

Explanation of Unity Engine Encryption Solutions
March 17, 2025

How to Anti Hack in Client-Side Games
May 21, 2025

Cocos Engine Encryption Solution
April 8, 2025

How Games Anti-Debugging
April 15, 2025

Cloud Phone Detection Solution for Gaming
May 21, 2025

How Games Detect Frida
March 25, 2025

How Games Detect PlayCover
March 26, 2025